AI's Double Edged Impact on Branding

We've always had a pulse on the forefront of technological innovation. AI has quickly become a useful part of our creative process, but its integration comes with its own set of challenges. In this article, we will examine both successful and unsuccessful uses of AI by well-known brands. By analyzing these three cases, we hope to provide valuable insights for other brands considering taking a stance on AI.

Dove's "Real Beauty" Stance

Dove’s stance on AI is an important one; they’ve managed to stay true to their brand values while still accepting that AI is becoming an essential tool in our society. Dove's commitment to "Real Beauty" has long been a cornerstone of its brand identity. Dove has become the first beauty brand to commit to never using Artificial Intelligence (AI) to represent women in its advertising. They took a bold stance against the rising tide of AI-generated content due to research confirming its potential to further distort beauty standards. 

“At Dove, we seek a future in which women get to decide and declare what real beauty looks like, not algorithms,” says Alessandro Manfredi, Chief Marketing Officer for Dove. Dove’s stance on AI included creating the "Real Beauty Prompt Guidelines," the brand aims to empower creators and users of generative AI programs to prioritize diversity and authenticity in their creations. This initiative serves as a blueprint for change, encouraging the development of AI models that reflect the true spectrum of female beauty.

Dove's decision is not merely a marketing ploy but a proactive response to alarming statistics revealed in their research conducted. With AI-generated content poised to dominate the online landscape, the brand recognized the urgent need to safeguard against the homogenization and unrealistic portrayals that AI can inadvertently perpetuate. 

Toys"R"Us: AI-Generated Video Campaign

Toys “R” Us has sparked online backlash after releasing an ad created with OpenAI’s new video generation tool, Sora. The 66-second promo takes us on a journey back to the 1930s, following young Charles Lazarus, the visionary founder of Toys "R" Us. 

AI-generated film has sparked diverse reactions on social media. Some viewers see it as an exciting glimpse into the future of content creation, where imagination is the only limit. Others, however, have expressed reservations. Some found the AI-generated characters "creepy," falling into the infamous "uncanny valley" where digital renderings of humans are close to realistic but just off enough to be unsettling. Others noticed inconsistencies in the AI-generated images, highlighting the current limitations of the technology. These mixed reactions underscore the ongoing challenges and opportunities in AI-generated content. As the technology continues to evolve, it will be fascinating to see how creators address these issues and refine their techniques.

The Toys "R" Us AI-generated brand film represents more than just a single company's marketing strategy: It's a significant milestone in the evolving landscape of content creation and brand storytelling. As AI tools like Sora become more sophisticated and widely available, we will likely see an increase in AI-generated content across various industries. This could democratize content creation, allowing smaller brands and creators to produce high-quality visual content at a fraction of the traditional cost. One thing's for sure, whether you're excited or skeptical about AI in marketing, this project has certainly got people talking. And for a brand looking to recapture the public's imagination after a period of uncertainty, that might be the most valuable outcome of all.

Levi's AI-Generated Models: A Step Too Far?

In 2023, Levi's faced backlash for partnering with Lalaland.ai to use AI-generated models in their online marketing campaigns. While AI can be a valuable tool in expanding representation, it should not be used as a substitute for genuine efforts to cast diverse models and create inclusive campaigns. The successes and failures of these AI initiatives offer valuable insights for brands considering similar ventures.

The integration of AI into your business is a double-edged sword. It demands a heightened sense of responsibility as brands must consider the potential impact of their AI-driven initiatives, ensuring they align with their values and resonate with their target audience.

As we continue to explore the vast potential of AI, it is crucial to remember that technology is merely a tool. The true magic lies in the human ingenuity that guides its application. At Interact, we advocate for a balanced approach, where AI enhances the human touch rather than replacing it. We think AI can be a powerful tool for generating ideas, automating tasks, and analyzing data, but it is the human touch that breathes life into a brand. It is our responsibility to guide AI's application with empathy, integrity, and a deep understanding of our audience's needs and desires.

What do you think? Which of these campaigns were truly successful? Were the benefits of brand awareness outweighed by potential ethical concerns? We leave it to you to decide. The future of AI in branding is bright, but it is up to us to shape it with purpose and responsibility. 

‍